I haven’t done a proper science post for a while and I’m sorry for that. I saw a news story pop up on Twitter from the ESA Science Team (@esascience) about the origin of Earth’s water. Just where did it come from?
This is an area that really interests me, in fact I get rather too excited about it. We had a long and detailed question on it pop up in S283 (an OU planetary science course) and I thoroughly enjoyed researching and developing my answer. I leapt at this chance to discuss it further.
It’s pretty obvious surely? Comets right? They’re mainly composed of water ice, we know the planets were pummeled by them in the late heavy bombardment about 4 billion years ago, its got to be them hasn’t it?
There has been no way to test this hypothesis until very recently. You need to send a spacecraft to a comet to test it – a very expensive but totally worthwhile test.
Now we’ve finally managed to study 4 comets in detail and the results are interesting. What we need to study is what’s called the deuterium/hydrogen isotope ratio. Deuterium is just basically a slightly heavier version of hydrogen, it has an extra neutron (technically not an extra one because hydrogen doesn’t have any neutrons).
If comets are the origin of the Earth’s water we’d expect there to be a very similar ratio of hydrogen and deuterium to the ratio of these isotopes in ocean water. From the comets that have been studied it turns out that this probably isn’t the case. Comets appear to have twice as much deuterium than ocean water, meaning that comets are an unlikely cause for our waters origins. As we’ve said already though, only a few comets have been analysed in detail. They might not be representative of all comets.
Another theory states that water-bearing grains are responsible. The distance from the Sun at which the Earth formed though casts doubt on this. It would have been so warm that water couldn’t have existed here. Not if they were incorporated within hydrated minerals though. As the planet formed (and after) these hydrated minerals would, over time, degas out into the atmosphere via volcanic eruptions. Eventually, enough was degassed to form today’s oceans. This has been held as the most plausible explanation.
A spanner seems to have been thrown in the works though, the debate has been reignited. The Herschel infrared space observatory has been looking at comet Hartley 2 and has found that its deuterium/hydrogen ratio is pretty much exactly the same as Earth’s oceans. This comet is suspected to originally have been a trans-Neptunian object flung into the inner solar system have a gravitational tug of war. These comets, forming under different conditions to those that formed between Jupiter and Saturn, probably have slightly different compositions, specifically the deuterium/hydrogen ratio.
A recent study shows that there was likely a 5th giant planet in the solar system, but after gravitational encounters with other planets was flung out of the solar system, stirring up all the trans-Neptunian comets on its way. Is this the reason for the late heavy bombardment? It lends weight to comets being the origin of Earth’s water.
I’m still sceptical though. This is only one comet. We’re going to need to study many, many more before we reach a definitive conclusion. From what I’ve studied, hydrated minerals seem to fit best with the available evidence, but as more comes in I’m willing to change my mind.
- Definition of a Planet in the Solar System (articles4friends.com)
- Comets may have helped seeds of life to germinate (yorkshirepost.co.uk)
- New evidence that comets deposited building blocks of life on primordial Earth (naturenplanet.com)
- NASA Juno MIssion Will Prove Earth Origin (acksblog.firmament-chaos.com)
- Kuiper Belt (articles4friends.com)